BRANCHBURG — The 72-year-old umpire who suffered a broken jaw and concussion at a youth baseball game has filed a lawsuit against the parent-coach charged with punching him.

James Neely was officiating a 13U baseball game at White Oak Park in Branchburg on June 4 when a coach for a visiting Staten Island team began cursing at him with "extensive profanity" in front of the young players, according to the lawsuit.

The civil complaint said Neely ejected the coach, identified as Jerry Otero, 40, of Staten Island. In response, the parent-coach punched Neely "without warning or justification."

Otero is charged with aggravated assault and assault at a youth sports event. Acting Somerset County Prosecutor Annmarie Taggart said Otero fled from the scene before police arrived but turned himself in over two weeks later.

The entrance to White Oak Park in Branchburg. (Google Maps)
The entrance to White Oak Park in Branchburg. (Google Maps)

"Our focus has to be the kids," Neely said in a statement. "We need to ensure that youth sports remain a place for them to learn and grow in a safe environment. I hope to be out there on the field one day soon for the kids."

Along with Otero, the lawsuit names the New York Prospects, the Prospects' president Frank Cambria, and the US Amateur Baseball League, which ran the tournament that day. The Prospects is a non-profit that operates youth baseball teams in Staten Island.

Neely is also suing the parents of the Staten Island team, who have not yet been identified. The lawsuit claimed that the parents encouraged the assault by yelling at Neely and taunting him after the punch.

At least one parent was heard saying that Neely "got what he deserved,” according to the suit.

Neely had remained unnamed until his attorney, Andrew O'Conner, announced the lawsuit on Tuesday.

"People's behavior at youth travel sports have become completely out of control," O'Conner said. "Now we will seek justice for Mr. Neely in the courts, and make sure the kids at all sport events are protected."

Rick Rickman is a reporter for New Jersey 101.5. You can reach him at

Click here to contact an editor about feedback or a correction for this story.

Beautiful sunflower fields to visit in NJ 2022

Among reasons why the “Garden State” remains a fitting nickname for New Jersey — late summer means the arrival of sunflower season.

There are at least six fields, spanning the state. Some are in bloom as of early August, while others are planned to peak from late August to late September.

Calling or emailing before heading out is always advisable if weather appears to be an issue. 

Here's where NJ legal weed is sold

The number of recreational cannabis dispensaries continues to grow, with close to two dozen state approvals given since the first adult recreational sales in the state back in April. Here is where the open sites are located.

Netflix’s Most Popular English-Language TV Shows Ever

These are the most popular TV shows ever on Netflix (in English), based on hours viewed in their first 28 days on streaming.

More From New Jersey 101.5 FM