"El Presidente" aka Dave Portnoy of Barstool Sports has become famous for reviewing pizzerias throughout the country.  Over the last week, he hit the Jersey Shore four times while avoiding the best pizzerias we have to offer.  Let's investigate.

Credit: Jonathan M. - Yelp
Credit: Jonathan M. - Yelp

I'll say this, I LOVE pizza.  I'm a Long Island native and loved the pie out there.  I also lived in Connecticut and enjoyed Sally's and Pepe's, two legendary pie makers.  Since moving to New Jersey a year ago, I've found several amazing Jersey Shore pizzerias.  And Portnoy's avoiding them!

Let's review his stops and scores:

So, the places he visited ranged from a 4.8 to a 7.5.  Respectable, but not impressive.

Why hasn't he went to the BEST pizzerias at the Jersey Shore?  After trying and reviewing over 500 slices across the country, he's doing himself a disservice by not trying and enjoying our best.  El Presidente, I challenge you to try these and rate them.

Ocean County's Top 5 Pizzerias

  • Pies on Nine in Beachwood
  • Maruca's Tomato Pies in Seaside Heights (7.5 this week. Boom done!)
  • Capone's in Toms River
  • Pietros Pizza in Manahawkin
  • Lenny's Pizza in Lavallette

Monmouth County's Top 4 Pizzerias

  • Pete & Elda's in Neptune City (reviewed in 2020 and given an 8.1. Boom!)
  • Vic's in Bradley Beach
  • Squan Tavern in Manasquan
  • Attilio's in Freehold

I think all of these would garner an 8 or higher.  What say, you Dave Portnoy?  The challenge is on!

The Most Delicious Italian Restaurants in Monmouth County

More From New Jersey 101.5 FM