Voters in Franklin Lakes are being asked to give an opinion in on what the town’s own leaders won’t. 

A ballot question will be asked on Nov. 3 as to whether the borough should consider a deer cull using professional bow hunters annually for three years. The referendum is nonbinding. So a yes vote wouldn’t automatically launch a hunt, but would give borough officials an idea of whether residents support the idea.

The Debate 

Supporters say the deer population has gotten out of control, contributing to vehicle accidents, damaged vegetation and environmental problems. A Raritan Valley Community College study estimates roughly 62 deer per square mile in that area according to nj.com.

Opponents argue killing deer is unnecessary and that nonlethal alternatives should be considered. Didn’t we hear the same argument against hunting when Gov. Murphy stripped away 40% of land available to bear hunters? The result was a rising and problematic bear population. His own wildlife experts explained to him non-lethal alternatives are not sufficiently effective and here we are still arguing this? An online petition opposing the proposal has attracted hundreds of signatures. I find this horribly misguided. 

Tragedies 

The debate comes at a particularly sobering time.

On Oct. 19, a 69-year-old Galloway Township woman was killed when a deer struck by an eastbound car was thrown airborne into her westbound vehicle on Moss Mill Road. It hit her windshield and she was pronounced dead at the scene.

Think about that for a moment. The deer didn’t simply damage a bumper or leave a driver shaken on the side of the road. A woman lost her life in a freak chain of events involving an animal and two vehicles. It's far from the first human fatality caused by a deer. 

Nobody should pretend that a deer-management program would prevent every crash. But it’s a reminder that deer overpopulation isn’t just about expensive shrubs and gardens getting eaten. This is a serious problem that needs a serious solution. 

The question is, do the voters in Franklin Lakes have the stomach to call for it? 

Franklin Lakes officials aren’t endorsing either side. Of course not. That would involve leadership. Even if voters favor the proposal, the town would still need to develop a plan and obtain approval from New Jersey Fish & Wildlife before any cull could proceed.

It’s a difficult debate, pitting concerns about animal welfare against public safety and the environment. On Nov. 3, Franklin Lakes voters will decide.

NJ voter turnout by county in the 2025 gubernatorial election

We list the state's 21 counties by voter turnout — the percentage of registered voters who cast a ballot in the 2025 election. Each county entry includes the turnout for each municipality listed in alphabetical order, and the candidate who won the most votes in each town and county. We also list the percentage of ballots that were mail-in.

Gallery Credit: New Jersey 101.5

How New Jersey decorated their homes for Halloween 2026

We asked NJ1015.com readers to show off their decorations for Halloween 2026 and had a hauntingly good time checking them out.

Gallery Credit: Kylie Moore

Opinions expressed in the post above are those of New Jersey 101.5 talk show host Jeff Deminski only.

Report a correction 👈

More From New Jersey 101.5 FM