Contact Us
Make My Homepage

11 NJ ice cream shops you NEED to visit

What better way to celebrate the return of appropriate spring weather, than with ice cream?

(In a bold move this weekend, I put the winter coats deeper into the closet. So it’ll probably be freezing tomorrow.)

The best NJ ice cream shops to visit! (altrendo images, ThinkStock)
The best NJ ice cream shops to visit! (altrendo images, ThinkStock)

These days, you could rank ice cream alongside bagels and pizza as things Jersey does best. From soft serve with *sprinkles* (that’s right, I commit to the term)…to small batch flavors.  Here’s the best spots to go (in no particular order, mind you)!

But wait … before we get carried away, if we missed one, we want to know about it! Tweet me @ProudJersey and at @NJ1015 and let me know what you think.


1. Magnifico’s (East Brunswick)

With more than 30 years in the biz, you better believe the ice cream is good! From soft serve, to hard ice cream, birthday cakes and ice cream-filled cannolis — they have it all. Among new menu items calling my name — the Hot Chocolate Lava Cake Sundae.

~Hot Apple Pie Sundae~ #magnificosicecream #sundae #icecream

A photo posted by @magnificosicecream on

But, the above pic is a seasonal favorite, too — apple pie sundae! Magnifico’s on Route 18 is open daily, from 11 a.m. to 10 p.m.


2. Cliff’s Homemade Ice Cream (Ledgewood)

Ice Cream! #huckleberrybuckle #cliffshomemadeicecream

A photo posted by Vincent (@vinni6687) on

Cliff’s has been a “neighborhood icon” (as it’s billed) since 1975! The menu could immobilize you, with over 11 flavors of soft ice cream and over 60 kinds of hard, hand-dipped ice cream. That’s not counting seasonal specials. Good places to start? Holy Cannoli, “Morris County Mud” or Lemon Raspberry Shandy.

Cliff’s is on Route 46 West, within a mile of Routes 10, 80 and 206.

Editor’s note: I can’t believe Erin left out the Denville Dairy, just a few towns over! I’ve you’ve spent time around Morris County, the Denville Dairy vs. Cliff’s question is definitional. They’re both great I’m on Team DD. — Lou Hochman


3. Jake’s Cree-Mee Freeze (Manalapan)

Jake’s is another landmark seasonal shop. Have your cash in-hand (no cards here), for soft serve or hard ice cream, frozen yogurt and even a Creamsicle Orange & Vanilla Swirl. Jake’s also does shakes, malts, rootbeer floats and ice cream sodas.


4. Cookman Creamery (Asbury Park)

The clever tag line here “Whatever churns you on!” Along with Asbury’s bustling scene along Cookman Avenue, this is your year-round spot for a sweet treat. (My family just visited for the first time, and will return.)

Tip: be sure you know which menu you’re ordering from. I can attest to the quality of their vegan Irish coffee, but I would have been fine ordering from the Traditional menu.


5. Heavenly Havens Creamery(Allentown and Hamilton)

We are working on getting our new sign! Here is a sneak peeking what is to come in Hamilton! #icecream #photoshop #route33 #hamiltonnj

A photo posted by Heavenly Havens Creamery (@heavenlyhavenscreamery) on

These two stores used to be Swal Dairy, and still serve the same ice cream. The former owners have moved on to expand production, with plans for a wholesale location in Monmouth.

Friday night date #heavenlyhavenscreamery #squirrelsgonenuts #ohhowivemissedthis

A photo posted by @joiful1970 on

So even by a new name, there’s plenty of home-made ice cream, Italian ice and yogurt, whether on Main Street in Allentown or Route 33 in Hamilton.


6.The Bent Spoon (Princeton)

we're feeling a little nutty today! pistachio, walnut streak & hazlnut ice creams today! #smallbatch #icecream #since2004

A photo posted by the bent spoon (@thebentspoon) on

From classic to unique flavors, there’s a handcrafted ice cream for every taste.

There’s often a line outside the Princeton business, because as frequent visitors note, “It’s that good.” The Bent Spoon also offers baked goods, tea and coffee.


7. Holsten’s (Bloomfield)

They said to eat soft foods, so I did

A photo posted by Juliana Stephan (@juliana.stephan) on

Aside from it’s long history serving up yummy sundaes, Holsten’s has a whole other fan base for being the final scene of HBO’s Sopranos.

So, after taking a ‘booth selfie’ a la Tony and Carmela, be sure to try out a Marshmallow sundae or maybe an Egg Cream (yes, they still make ’em).

Holsten’s Brookdale Confectionery also offers a diner-type menu and an extensive candy selection.


8. Petrucci’s Inside Scoop (Piscataway)

ice cream stop #homemade #homemadeicecream #petruccisinsidescoop #mintchocolatechip #blackraspberry #toastedcoconut

A photo posted by Karen Atkinson (@kyny1213) on

Pettrucci’s is a central Jersey mainstay, offering homemade ice cream and Italian ice, ice cream cakes, plus chocolate covered bananas. On most GPS devices, it comes up as Pettruci’s Dairy Barn.


9. Frosty Freeze (Garwood)

Reunited and it feels so good

A photo posted by Juliana Mazza (@indiejem) on

For newbies to the Union County area, this is a seasonal “must-visit” in Garwood.

A nice balmy evening will see the North Avenue spot bustling with local families. Since it’s been less than balm, the hours have been a bit varied — but as they put it on Facebook, they’re “generally open 1 p.m. to 9 p.m.”


10. Gabriel’s Fountain (Martinsville)

Start your day off the right way… With Jelly Doughnut! ❤️ @icecream #gabesfaves #getspooned #smallbatchicecream #icecream

A photo posted by Gabriels Fountain (@gabrielsfountainrestaurant) on

Go for the homemade ice cream, stay for lunch or dinner. “Legendary” flavors ranging from the classics to Scarlett Knight, Spongebob and Grasshopper Pie. The menu includes Pistachio Affogato, “two scoops of homemade ice cream ‘affogato’ (drowned) in a shot of fresh brewed espresso.”

Yes-we-can goals=Weekend goals @icecream #gabesfaves #smallbatchicecream #icecream #spooning #weekendgoals

A photo posted by Gabriels Fountain (@gabrielsfountainrestaurant) on

The Somerset County restaurant also offers “ice cream tours,” which could make for a fun birthday outing at any age.


11. Milk Sugar Love (Jersey City)

Another rising star on the ice cream scene, Milk Sugar Love in Jersey City offers 12 flavors daily. The four available every day: Vanilla Bean, Salted Caramel, Classic Chocolate and Lemon Olive Oil. The rest change with the season.

Milk Sugar Love also offers a pet lover’s perk: Puppy FroYo (made from peanut butter, banana and yogurt). And, I leave you with this suggestion- Red Velvet cakewiches!


Proud Jersey Girl Erin Vogt’s first reporting gig involved her Fisher Price tape recorder. As a wife and momma of two kiddies, she firmly believes that life’s too short to drink bad coffee.  A fan of the beach, Dave Grohl and karma, in no particular order.

Follow her on Twitter and on Facebook as ProudJersey.

Best of NJ101.5

Recommended For You

Best of the Web

Leave a Comment

It appears that you already have an account created within our VIP network of sites on . To keep your personal information safe, we need to verify that it's really you. To activate your account, please confirm your password. When you have confirmed your password, you will be able to log in through Facebook on both sites.

Forgot your password?

*Please note that your prizes and activities will not be shared between programs within our VIP network.

It appears that you already have an account on this site associated with . To connect your existing account just click on the account activation button below. You will maintain your existing VIP profile. After you do this, you will be able to always log in to using your original account information.

*Please note that your prizes and activities will not be shared between programs within our VIP network.

Please fill out the information below to help us provide you a better experience.

(Forgot your password?)

Not a member? Sign up here

Sign up for New Jersey Insiders quickly by connecting your Facebook account. It's just as secure and no password to remember!

Sign up to have exclusive New Jersey Insiders contests, events, coupons, presales, and much more delivered to you for FREE.