Dennis and Judi were discussing Justin Timberlake's surprise appearance last night at Maxwell's in Hoboken. They both agreed that they don't get his popularity or his music.Have they gotten old and just don't get him? Or is Justin Timberlake totally overrated and not worth the hype he gets?

Do you agree with Dennis and Judi or do you think they are totally off base? Take our poll below and let us know what you think.